May 17, 2019

New York-Style Oreo Cheesecake

Name: New York-Style Oreo Cheesecake
Prep time: 30 min
Cook time: 1 h 20 min
Total time: 7 h 50 min
Yield: 9" Cheesecake
Cuisine: Cheesecake
Ingredients: 24 Oreo cookies; 1/4 cup (4 Tablespoons) unsalted butter, melted; 3 (8 ounce) packages full-fat cream cheese, very soft; 1 cup full-fat sour cream; 1 and 1/4 cups granulated sugar; 3 large eggs plus 2 large egg yolks, at room temperature; 1/2 cup heavy cream; 16 Oreo cookies, roughly chopped, divided

This New York-Style Oreo Cheesecake is thick, creamy and loaded with Oreo cookies! Serves a crowd and is a big hit with kids and adults! Freeze any leftovers for up to two months!

Oreo Cheesecake

My love affair with cheesecake began in my early twenties, when I was a waitress at – wait for it – the cheesecake factory! I know a lot of folks who hate on that place, but if I’m being completely honest, I loved it. Heck, I still love it.

I had a lot of fun working there and met a ton of great friends. And I also learned that I LOVE cheesecake. Sadly, I don’t have any top secret recipes or anything like that. But I do think a lot of my recipes are inspired by the ones I ate there years ago. Just take a little peak in the cheesecake recipe archive and you’ll see what I mean. There may be more cheesecake recipes on my blog than anything else! And there are MANY more to come. So I hope you guys love cheesecake as much as I do!!!

Cheesecake Factory Oreo Cheesecake

But I digress! Today’s recipe for rich and creamy New York-Style Oreo Cheesecake was definitely inspired by my days slinging cheesecake at the CCF! Funny enough, the cheesecake factory Oreo cheesecake was not my favorite. But this homemade version is one best cheesecakes I’ve ever made! I think it’s because I used the batter for my tried and true New York-Style Cheesecake, and then just added a ton of Oreo’s! Because why mess with perfection, right?

Oh, and I also added an Oreo crust. And some more Oreo cookies on top! Because an Oreo cheesecake recipe should use as many Oreo cookies as possible, right?

Because I’m a more is more person, I finished this cheesecake off with a dollop of freshly whipped cream. Suffice it to say, this cheesecake is NOT diet food. But it is delicious, decadent, and, in my opinion, worth every single calorie. And that’s coming from a girl who hates the treadmill with passion! #willrunforcheesecake

And if you’re interested in making this already decadent cheesecake even more sinful, try topping it with chocolate ganache. You can use this recipe.

Make the Oreo Crust

To make the crust you will need melted butter and crushed Oreo cookies. Yep – just two ingredients! You do not need to remove the cream from the center of the cookies.

Simply place them in a blender or food processor and pulverize them into small crumbs. Once they’re crushed, you will combine them with the melted butter and then press this mixture into your prepared pan. And that’s that. You just made a homemade cheesecake crust!

When pressing the Oreo crust down into the bottom of the springform pan, you’re going to want to press it down very firmly. A firmly packed crust will bake up nice and thick, and most importantly, won’t crumble too much when sliced. I recommend starting to press the crumbs down in the center of the pan, then working the crust out and just a little bit up the edges. You can use the back of a spoon to do this, or wrap your hand in a piece of plastic wrap (also known as saran wrap) and do it manually.

Room Temperature Ingredients…

Room temperature ingredients are crucial when it comes to making a cheesecake! So be sure you bring your cream cheese, eggs, sour cream, and heavy cream to room temp before you begin making the batter.

P.S. The batter can be made in a food processor, high powered blender, or add all of the ingredients to a bowl and combine with a hand mixer. I use my blender!

Whip it Good

It’s very important to beat the cream cheese and sour cream until smooth before adding the other ingredients. No matter what you use to make your batter, be sure to scrape down the sides of the container while you’re blending, so you don’t get “surprised” with lumps of cream cheese later.

Once it’s silky smooth and lump free, you’ll add in the sugar, and then the eggs one at a time. Before pouring in the cream and then finally folding in the Oreo cookies. If you want an extra chocolate fix, you could also throw in a handful of chocolate chips at this point. But this is optional.

Is a Water bath Necessary?

And finally, we need to talk about the dreaded water bath. I say dreaded because I know so many folks fear making one or have had really bad experiences with them. But baking your cheesecake in one is a must if you want silky smooth, creamy, crack free results. My big tips here are to wrap your pan in multiple layers of heavy duty aluminum foil and to only fill the pan up an inch.

And you’ll want to push the cheesecake into the oven very carefully, so that the water doesn’t move around too much. Many reader’s have told me they sometimes use a crockpot liner in addition to ensure no water gets in; I’ve never tried this but wanted to through the idea out there in case you want to give it a shot.

If you’re not up for trying a traditional water bath – or just ran out of aluminum foil – you can place your spring form pan in a larger pan, and then place them in an even larger pan. Then fill that pan with a few inches of water. Does that make sense?

Avoid Browning…

If the top of your cheesecake starts to look a little too brown, simply cover the pan wit a piece of foil or parchment paper.

Let it Cool!

When you remove the cheesecake from the oven, it will need to cool – in the pan – for at least 30 minutes before being covered and placed in the fridge to chill completely. You will keep the oreo cheesecake in the pan until it’s completely chilled. The remove the sides of pan and serve.

This Oreo Cheesecake can be baked, fully cooled, and frozen for up to two months! Making it a perfect holiday dessert option.

Simply thaw the night before you plan on serving! And don’t be surprised when your friends think you bought this oreo cheesecake from a fancy bakery. It’s seriously that impressive!

And if you try this recipe for New York-Style Oreo Cheesecake, let me know! Leave a comment below and don’t forget to snap a pic and tag it #bakerbynature on instagram! Seeing your kitchen creations makes my day.

More Oreo Recipes:

14 votes